The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Knoxii]

hi!! im a returning player who's trying to get a grip on the rarity system again;
i'd like to hear some thoughts on this attempted trade!

here was a suggestion that the other person edited my og trade to:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110888285&userid=676624&signature=H00k6y9H2eK4uLseJIh4Yg

and here's the one i edited after consulting horror's guide:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110894285&userid=676624&signature=EqNOB5_TztzYfWhAqX1E2A

was what i offered the second time unfair??

[jprspereira]

I need help with this trade, UR Phoenix for a bunch of old store pets and I'm not sure if is fair.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110906158&userid=413084&signature=wP2OfpJrHU87-xuhs1uhPQ

Hey, I'm on the other side of the trade. This is how I valued the pets:

Cheshire (2013) - 5MA
Alpaca (2013) - 1MA
Kitsunes (each) - 2.5MA, so 10MA total
Corgis (each) - 1.5MA, so 4.5MA total
Total: 20.5MA.

My side:
2015 store - 0.5MA
UR Phoenix - 20MA, based on the Successful trade Thread, where people value it at 1.5 to 2 nons (15 to 20MA), but always goes for 2 nons (20MA) in the trades from the past year.

Let me know what you guys think

[bohnette.]

I get a little lost when comparing sides on bulk trades. Its 37 pets to 25 pets? Link.
Ty in advance ♡

[jprspereira]

hi!! im a returning player who's trying to get a grip on the rarity system again;
i'd like to hear some thoughts on this attempted trade!

here was a suggestion that the other person edited my og trade to:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110888285&userid=676624&signature=H00k6y9H2eK4uLseJIh4Yg

and here's the one i edited after consulting horror's guide:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110894285&userid=676624&signature=EqNOB5_TztzYfWhAqX1E2A

was what i offered the second time unfair??

Blue Balloon Bunny is worth 5 to 7 old rares 2010/2011.
The store cat from 2019 is worth 2 old rares (2010/2011)

1st trade:
You offered around 5 to 7 times more the worth of the bunny (Roughly 35 old rares on your side).

2nd trade:
You offered 3 to 4 times less the worth of the bunny.

I get a little lost when comparing sides on bulk trades. Its 37 pets to 25 pets? Link.
Ty in advance ♡

A bit hard to judge when it's this bulky, but your pets are a bit older than theirs is general so I'd say it looks fine if both sides are okay with it.

[weld]

are either of these fair? values are hard when you haven't played in like a year...

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110903319&userid=815492&signature=ESpUN2Zoj9FmwvhIiCViug
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110903579&userid=815492&signature=VgbS16MoucQt0FYDGKOlHA

[LUMENS8ITE]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110907455&userid=313850&signature=CHGJIAAhw0bE8HL6ztQ0pA
i don't really have a good understanding of converting pets to C$ so can anyone lmk if this is a fair offer?

[Knoxii]

hi!! im a returning player who's trying to get a grip on the rarity system again;
i'd like to hear some thoughts on this attempted trade!

here was a suggestion that the other person edited my og trade to:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110888285&userid=676624&signature=H00k6y9H2eK4uLseJIh4Yg

and here's the one i edited after consulting horror's guide:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110894285&userid=676624&signature=EqNOB5_TztzYfWhAqX1E2A

was what i offered the second time unfair??

Blue Balloon Bunny is worth 5 to 7 old rares 2010/2011.
The store cat from 2019 is worth 2 old rares (2010/2011)

1st trade:
You offered around 5 to 7 times more the worth of the bunny (Roughly 35 old rares on your side).

2nd trade:
You offered 3 to 4 times less the worth of the bunny.

hi! thank u so much!! this was really helpful for me, the rarity system seems to be everchanging. the first linked trade was their suggestion but i knew it seemed like a LOT.

[jprspereira]

Hey!
Just curious about this one!

Top is overpaying by about 2 MA per Horror's guide (top = 10 MA / bottom = nonballoon 5MA + 3 MA). However, lots of people are seeking trade-downs nowadays, and the pets on the bottom side have decent demand, so it's not a bad deal. That might make up for the value disparity.

The Nonballoon dog is True Date, so that alone could easily cover the gap of 2MA you mentioned in my opinion

[jprspereira]

are either of these fair? values are hard when you haven't played in like a year...

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110903319&userid=815492&signature=ESpUN2Zoj9FmwvhIiCViug
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110903579&userid=815492&signature=VgbS16MoucQt0FYDGKOlHA

1st trade:
Their side: 1MA + 2.5MA + 2.5MA = 6MA
Your side: BMD worth 5 to 7.5MA for re-release. Seems to be closer to 7.5MA however. So I'd say the above side could add 1.5MA.

2nd trade:

Based on Horror's list
Roadkill PPS: 1.5MA
Your side: 1MA + 0.25MA

So you'd need to add 0.25MA (say, a very rare 2009) to get to 1.5MA and if they value true date as the same as re-releases.

[ph0enicks]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110852299&userid=933740&signature=i0shfJBJqKMZzeUi2arfTQ

could someone help on this? i’m a bit tentative since mine is a store pet

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110852898&userid=933740&signature=RrVFmsPgqLbja0B_BcC4Hw

also is this fair? i’m not sure the worth of the kirin but it is my dreamie!!