The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Supreme]

Would love any help on these trades

Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3

Thank you!

[BillyBoi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111207721
my brother is stressed about whether or not this is a fair trade in case we get kicked for using the same laptop. i wanted to overpay cus it's a gift really but he's scared it's gonna get us in trouble. i used the how much is this worth in c$ thread is it ok?

Can't see this trade, try posting the link at the bottom of that page, not url on top.

ah sry here u go
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111207721&userid=526921&signature=jKTFTri-TKi-lDhGUdqhfw

Honestly if it’s a gift or a trade between friends/family usually a little unfairness is okay, try not to make it a regular thing as trades are patrolled for wildly unfair trades from people with multiple accounts but even in the CS rules it states it’s okay aslong as it’s not an all the time thing

[GhostPants]

Opinions on this trade =)?
*warning* slight bulk(?)
@ghostpants

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=109974557&userid=9355&signature=p4S154emLYueLxWJs-bZQQ Should I change this? Someone on the fair trade thread said. " Nick Blue Toxic is 1,5 MA. I think the older pets alone would be more fair:

Single-Colored RBM = 0,5 MA
09 VR = 0,25 MA
7 old rares = 0,7 MA

Would be 1,45 MA"

[Trott]

Recently returned after 6 years and going through the process of liquidating a huge portion of my old pets and items for ones that bring me more joy; unfortunately this means I am somewhat clueless in regards to the values of different things beyond "is it really old" and the site-determined rarity. ^^;

Could I please get some opinions on these two trades?
Their 2008 very rare dog for my Nick PPS moon dog

My turtle dove for their big assorted item bundle (all are on my wishlist) + some very recent WL token pets
Regarding this one, if it isn't fair, what would need added/removed in order to make it fair? The user has offered to add C$ as well. I know the turtle dove is (was?) valued at a mid '09 rare or very rare, but I don't know how that works out in a trade like this one.

Thank you for any advice that can be offered!

[Sugar Paw]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111056260&userid=228228&signature=LmGGPMRmcTNdoFhvSUORHg

Still curious about the fairness of this trade. I kept the coon but still would like to know!

[Sugar Paw]

Hi is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111224858&userid=1016753&signature=N89nivClSlMUhSnExPRhIg

I would say no, the african wild dog rabbit is worth way more than that. (2 for 1 rule, if two 2019's equal a 2018 and so on then your side would only be worth a 2017 very rare).

[KookyAlienQueen]

..

[birdiesong]

Hi is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111224858&userid=1016753&signature=N89nivClSlMUhSnExPRhIg

I would say no, the african wild dog rabbit is worth way more than that. (2 for 1 rule, if two 2019's equal a 2018 and so on then your side would only be worth a 2017 very rare).

actually the 2:1 rule isn’t a good idea for high value pets (including store pets).

the wild dog rabbit is worth 5-7 old rares.

the 2019 store lions and feathered griffins (? idk what their actual name is) are worth 2 old rares each. so for all 8 your side is worth 16 old rares, or 1.6 MAs. so this would be very very unfair to you.

plus those 2019 store lions are pretty popular and i personally think worth closer to 3 old rares each (especially as they get older) but that’s my personal opinion.

[KookyAlienQueen]

Hi is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111224858&userid=1016753&signature=N89nivClSlMUhSnExPRhIg

I would say no, the african wild dog rabbit is worth way more than that. (2 for 1 rule, if two 2019's equal a 2018 and so on then your side would only be worth a 2017 very rare).

I thought that store pets were valued differently compared to regular rares